I work for legal aid. We are unionized (attorneys and non-attorney support staff). We created what we thought was solidified job descriptions for our new contract (we are currently bargaining) and management came back to us with what I think is a shitty proposal. Thoughts?

Soo.. below are the proposals. The yellow is added language and the strikethru stuff is old language from the previous contract. This was our (union's) proposal: https://anonfiles.com/r8od1a61y0/Appendix_B1_Job_Classification_and_Promotion_in_Place_8.23.22_Redacted_pdf This was managements: https://anonfiles.com/q3o31d68yd/Counter_Job_Classification_and_Promotion_in_Place_8.23.22_Redacted_pdf I definitely think their proposal is kinda shitty. At least for the support staff descriptions, we are basically being exploited because they can assign us any work they want at management's discretion. It blows. What do you all think?